Too much colorfull and bit empty, as for me...
Third signature: face in the right corner needs more retouching... Mario I like most...
i really like the second one ... it's simple and carry a feeling !! ...
and also Mario is so cool
I also Like the last one (Mario) most.
They are all good art but I think there is some issues you may need to look at :-
- All of them needs a border (the common 1-px black border solves this issue in my opinion)
- The Second one needs a blur or a similar effect in some regions to fix the pixilated view(at the borders of the lightest colors: white and light green)
- All needs to make the text more readable than its current state..In my opinion, you may need to change text size, have a text effect, change blending options, or at least have a very small banner behind the text (just fits the text and have a curve somewhere - It is just a suggestion).
- The first signature have no text at all .. This gives it a very low rank in my opinion.
- In the last one (Mario) ..That large black space may need to be changed to another dark color with an effect like a shiny gradient or at least add an effect without changing the color.
Best In My opinion :-
- Best Model(Render) is Mario.
- Best Finishing and text is also Mario.
- Best Background and effects is the second one(Dev-il).
- First one : 7/10 .. The Model is good but needs some effort in the blending to look better.
- Second one : 8/10 .. The best in the matter of effects and background.
- Third one : 6/10 .. Models are not the best, background did not appear, and blending seemed not very good.
- Last one : 8.5/10 .. Model(Render) is the best, blending seems OK, effects are great .. but this black area is not the best as for me.(Only needs a border and some text effects)
Mario is the best I like that.
nice work but not very good.
Still i like the second last and last one.
Read the suggestions of my above poster.
I like Mario too second one is good too. but the mario is the best ;>
They seem a bit empty indeed
I don't find them empty, they are just perfect. I very like your signatures, they are awesome!