FRIHOSTFORUMSSEARCHFAQTOSBLOGSCOMPETITIONS
You are invited to Log in or Register a free Frihost Account!


P2P + Bittorrent = Illegal ? Do you think so?





poisonhzkj
In my oppion,neither of the technologies themeselves are illegal. The illegal part comes in when people use it to break copyright. Bittorrent is used for the distribution of linux builds among other things, and has quite a few useful purposes.
SNES350
poisonhzkj wrote:
In my oppion,neither of the technologies themeselves are illegal. The illegal part comes in when people use it to break copyright. Bittorrent is used for the distribution of linux builds among other things, and has quite a few useful purposes.

P2P (bittorrent included) is perfectly legal; as you said it is using it to violate copyright law that is illegal. Of course, the same could be said about the CD burner in a computer or a video camera. To the extreme, (moving away from copyright law...) pencils are illegal as they can be used to kill people. That is what the RIAA's logic will lead you to.
cavey
If bittorrent was illegal, they must also make all browsers, ftp-clients illegal. Hey, why not forbid internet! :)

I've seen several freeware programs getting distributed with bittorrent on their official webpages.
Bondings
The problem comes when these programs are being advertised for their illegal uses by the makers/owners.

You can also argue that decent efforts should be made to limit the illegal uses. And in most cases this isn't done.
halflife28
P2P is legal technology, but as with anything, you can also do things illegal with P2P. It's legal to use a knife to cut things, like foods but it is illegal to kill a person with a knife.

So the government is talking about making P2P illegal? So why the hell don't we just ban everything that could be used for illegal activity?

I personally use Bittorrent to download the latest ISO images for my favorite linux distro, Ubuntu.
CMA
P2P/bittorrent/other similar software... It's all as legal as you want it to be. They only stop being legal when people abuse copyright laws or share other illegal stuff (like some sorts of movies, if you know what I mean).
avk
aLL ARE LEGAL TILL THE TIME U WANT THEM TO BE..

AND THE TIME U USAE IT FOR PORN/NUDITY OR ALL SORT OF UNNEEDED THINGS THEN THEY TEND TO BE ILLEGEAL.

I THINK ALL GOT WHAT I MEANT TO SAY!!
alkady
Maybe on Mars it's illegal, But I'm sure on Earth it isn't. Just the people would upload illegal stuff encourages lawmakers and so on to push for new legistrations to make it illegal.

Right now the MPAA and the RIAA and the other Industry Associations are trying to make it illegal but are having a hard time doing so. It is possible for it one day to be illegal.
garionw
alkady wrote:
Maybe on Mars it's illegal, But I'm sure on Earth it isn't. Just the people would upload illegal stuff encourages lawmakers and so on to push for new legistrations to make it illegal.

Right now the MPAA and the RIAA and the other Industry Associations are trying to make it illegal but are having a hard time doing so. It is possible for it one day to be illegal.


If that was to happen, there would be a new technology that would take its place. It would start out leagle but eventually grow to become illeagle.

Companies can try as hard as they want to put copy prtection on the programs and softwear but its just never going to happen. Theres always going to be some smart cookie out there who will find a way to crack it
alkady
garionw wrote:
alkady wrote:
Maybe on Mars it's illegal, But I'm sure on Earth it isn't. Just the people would upload illegal stuff encourages lawmakers and so on to push for new legistrations to make it illegal.

Right now the MPAA and the RIAA and the other Industry Associations are trying to make it illegal but are having a hard time doing so. It is possible for it one day to be illegal.


If that was to happen, there would be a new technology that would take its place. It would start out leagle but eventually grow to become illeagle.

Companies can try as hard as they want to put copy prtection on the programs and softwear but its just never going to happen. Theres always going to be some smart cookie out there who will find a way to crack it


That is true, But this is also the kind of stuff that discourages people to get into the industry.

I myself have just recently launched a company, And althrough my Big Plans for the Big Days are still years away, I myself take piracy seriously and already have a few plans to slow down piracy of my future products by a few days.

But this is also the kind of stuff that discourages me to get into software, entertainment etc.
Kaisonic
I thought this issue was already finalized. The actual P2P and Bittorrent programs are quite legal; they allow users to share files with one another in a vast environment where thousands of people have access to your files.

The only problem of course is copyright infringement, where the files being accessed are ones that weren't created by the user and aren't allowed to be shared. Of course, there are some files that can be shared without user creation, but I'm sure all of that is underlined in clear black ink in the license agreement for whatever file you're working with.

Personally I think it's a great way for people to share things they create; upcoming bands, video editors, etc. I myself have a machinima video site (see sig) and have considered hosting my videos on P2P networks for the sake of bandwidth costs and ease of use.
Related topics
Illegal website and illegal downloads!
NBA Live 2005
BT (bittorrent) features on the webspace ?
Bittorrent
Major Piracy Bust Against Top Providers
BitTorrent is NOT Illegal
is it illegal to download tv shows?
Torrent tracker on your site
get around firewall
getting bittorrent working
There are legal uses for BitTorrent...
what is p2p
[soft] ¿Está muriéndose el eMule?
Can i be accused ?
Reply to topic    Frihost Forum Index -> General -> General Chat

FRIHOST HOME | FAQ | TOS | ABOUT US | CONTACT US | SITE MAP
© 2005-2011 Frihost, forums powered by phpBB.