game vs game question?

picsite

So it's a question I'm begging to ask everyone (sorry if it's been raised before).

The films for these 2 didn't come out at the same time, but at different times, hinting that they are afraid to see who would get a bigger audience, I think people prefer it IF the films come out at different times anyway, that way you can get your head around one of them before going to see the other.

The books, even better, I've never really favoured the Tolkien book, but JK Rowling's books..wow. Harry Potter fanatic, I'm always reading them, I can't help it

What's YOUR take anyway? HP or LOTR? Who would win in the long run and why?

Frag

Lord of the rings hands down, HP is a great piece of writing, but it cant top the epic of LOTR.

root

I agree with Frag. Harry Potter is well written but can't compete with LOTR

rip8fan1

If I'm not mistaken the first LOTR movie and a HP movie came out about the same time, and LOTR won that battle. Then they decided to move the HP movies, because they did not want to compete!

IF you are talking the entire experience (movies, books, merchandising, etc.), then LOTR wins because it is more epic, and it has been around a lot longer.

If you just talk books, I think HP would win, because they are easier to read, and aimed at 'kids'.

In 50 years, I believe LOTR will still be around, and still read, and talked about, while HP may not be!

Kelcey

I agree. I choose LOTR by far.

GAME VS 50 CENT
NBA Fixed?
MU VS LIVERPOOL
Which American Football team goes to Super Bowl
PSYCHONAUTS (xbox)

Mod Projects lots of info
Star Wars Next-Gen Games
Pats vs. Chargers
who have emulators.
Final Fantasy XII

You judge: Good customer service or bad customer service
Paying money for virtual items.. Good or rediculous?
The Ornage Box: Portal (Xbox 360 : Review)
Whos your best basketball center player in Beijing Olympics?
Free MMORPG VS Pay MMORPG