You are invited to Log in or Register a free Frihost Account!

An end to OS and distro debate (read)

There are at least 5 threads about 'Which linux distro is best for me' 'Which OS is best' etc. and they all start a fanboy flame war. Enough already.

Which OS is best?
This depends on how good you are with computers, how much you'd like to learn, your system specs and what you use it for.

There is absolutely nothing wrong with WinXP Pro, as long as you have a fast computer, don't want to use it for music or design production and properly protect it with a firewall and antispyware etc.
So, a rundown of the OSs:

Windows XP:
This OS is good for gaming and office/business usage. That's not to say others aren't as good at this, but it's included with most computers. It takes a hefty processor and lots of ram (256MB) just to run, and needs careful anti-malware protection. New users will not find things to difficult, although several elements are counter-intuitive.
Good for: Gamers, internet usage, simple document creation
Bad for: Slow PCs, Limited budget, support

Windows 2000 and older:
Better for slower processors. Not as cuddly as XP, the latest games and programs won't run and it's probably a little less stable. On the plus side, much faster. 98SE is probably the furthest back you should go.
Good for: Power users in that particular system, older computers, simple usage
Bad for: New users, Gamers

Far easier to use than Windows, more stable and generally nicer. On the down-side, more expensive and less software availability. The software that is there is good, though, and it has a great learning curve.
Good for: Image and music editing, new users, UNIX users, documents, internet
Bad For: Windows Power Users, Gamers

Linux (Ubuntu):
Very easy to use after the initial installation but a sharpish learning curve to become a power user. Limited but growing number of games and third-party software. Uses fewer resources than Windows. Can also be used for advanced tasks like webserving and network management. Good programming and design tools. Free.
Good for: New Users, Basic users willing to learn a little, Gamers (sort of), programmers, graphics and music, geeks
Bad For: Windows power users with no capacity to learn

Linux (SuSE):
Much the same as Ubuntu, but even easier to use. To the point, however, that it becomes more difficult for semi-power users to accomplish tasks due to the babying nature of the admin tools.
Good For: (see above) + Especially new users
Bad For: Linux Power Users

Linux (Red Hat):
More of an enterprise distro, this one's better than Ubuntu and Suse for complex network tasks and such, but actually worse than Ubuntu as an office PC.

Linux (Slackware):
Less user-friendly than any of the above, a no-nonsense distro. Newbs may stay far, far away.

Well, I hope that cleared the water a bit. Feel free to start a fanboy flame war now, but do so in this thread and stop wasting space.
Nice Review.

But this is not gonna stop the flame war. This will be a feel good post for both people providing points for debate for the both.
Nice review as well.
You forgot to mention knoppix which is for me the easiest distro to set up and to learn with.
Yes, that's a pretty good review.

There are hundreds of Linuxes that he didn't mention. Wink

I personally think that Mac is good for gamers also. The only problem could be finding the games, but probably most big games are available for Mac.
It differs per case and it's hard to define a standard idea of what is good for who. Each person is different. And fanboys are just annoying ;o
good job with this review
And what about Windows 2003 Server on desktop? Does anyone have experience with it?
There are zillions of Linux distros. I picked Ubuntu because it won best desktop linux at some award or other, Red Hat because it's the best enterprise one, SuSE because it's a good typical starter distro and Slackware because it's a typical 1337 distro.
Related topics
Creating a new Operating System
NTFS and FAT32
Choosing a Distro
God a superstition?
[PHP] Faking Shell Access Through PHP
assembly compiler problem
FireFox sued
Is there only ONE God?
DOES GOD EXIST?-- the grand old debate
World leading OS
Climate debate - READ ME!
State representative vs. Tea Bagger
Youtube allows disabling commenting of videos with agenda?
Reply to topic    Frihost Forum Index -> Computers -> Software

© 2005-2011 Frihost, forums powered by phpBB.