FRIHOST FORUMS SEARCH FAQ TOS BLOGS COMPETITIONS
You are invited to Log in or Register a free Frihost Account!


Cut down on forum catagories?





Blaster
Well I understand why we had all the forum catagories but now I think it is causing less people to post especially with slower internet connections. I think if we were to slim down the catagories people would have less of a problem searching for topics. I usually just look in General chat because that is the easiest place. I don't have a lot of time to post and can't go looking for an interesting topic all over the place.
deanhills
That should be fun ....Wonder whether it could be set up in a way that the topics keep on moving one down so that the same ones aren't always on top. Like a vertical sliding effect.
Think
Nameless
I agree with this suggestion exactly as much as I have every time that it's come up and not been made to happen. Sad
Ankhanu
I dunno, there's a lot on here that I have zero interest in. Having the categories means that I can check what I want and never have to deal with all the categories I'm not interested in; oddly enough, it actually reduces clutter.
truespeed
All the topics in the entertainment and sports categories could be put into one single category called entertainment and sport. (Apart from Vehicles and Transportation,that could be placed elsewhere)
deanhills
truespeed wrote:
All the topics in the entertainment and sports categories could be put into one single category called entertainment and sport. (Apart from Vehicles and Transportation,that could be placed elsewhere)
Good point. And the Phil&Rel Forum should probably be separate as well with a cautionary note attached to it. Twisted Evil
Blaster
We could have it so we have just like a Science forum and not all these types of sub forums. That would take 6 down to 1. You could have a businness forum that would add Jobs and learning economics and marketing These are just a few ideas I could think of a bunch more.
Ankhanu
Blaster wrote:
We could have it so we have just like a Science forum and not all these types of sub forums. That would take 6 down to 1. You could have a businness forum that would add Jobs and learning economics and marketing These are just a few ideas I could think of a bunch more.

And all I think of is sifting through all the math based threads to see if there are any about biology Wink
Compartmentalization is convenience.
ocalhoun
Okay... get this...

Suppose we keep the categories, but add a mouse-over effect on each one.
Hovering the mouse over it will bring up a list of the, say, 10 most recently posted-in threads (the first ten in the section, not counting stickies and announcements).

Then, you can quickly look through the various sections without having to open each one.
Blaster
Honestly I think its just time to get rid of some forums...I'm not gonna put my mouse over each catagorie either. That would be just as annoying
Ankhanu
I kinda like the mouse-over thing.

Really, I don't quite understand the aversion to sub-forums; there are a lot of subjects that each of us have no interest in, and they're different for each of us. Having the categories means that we don't need to bother with entire sections of the board to find what we want. I can understand some sub-forums being combined, particularly where certain forums get almost no traffic... in this case, the separation doesn't really serve much purpose.

I also don't understand the time argument that you're putting forward, Blaster. I find that the sub-forums speed things up quite nicely for me. I come to the forum index and run a quick scroll down, noting whether or not there are updates in the sub-forums that interest me... if there's activity, I check them, if there's not, I don't. I know with a single scroll swipe whether or not there might be something of interest on the forum. Without the separation, I'd have to pay more attention to actual thread titles within buckets of topics, rather than a quick orange or white scan of the whole thing. Frequently I'm here and gone within 15 seconds, and I spend a little longer if it looks like there's something of interest on the go. Removing, for example, the Science sub-forums would slow me down dramatically.

EDIT - I do agree with some need for revision of the sub-forum categories themselves, but I'm not sure the number of sub-forums is an issue, so much as the usefulness of certain distinctions, or lack or distinctions.
Ghost Rider103
There is really no need to cut down on the forums. Most of them are there because there is/was a demand for it and is/was active.

Deleting some of the forums would give users less of an option to post about. Years ago I would have agreed with you. But you have to look at the big picture. This is a post to host website. We basically need to cover every subject so every person has an area that interest them that they can go to and post in. Other than general chat.

Reorganizing the forums is different though and highly needed. It might cut down 2 or 3 forums if done correctly as there are some duplicates that aren't needed in my opinion (I.e filmmaking and personal photos, your photos can basically be posted in filmmaking, as a lot of users do).

Removing forums I dont think is an option, I think that is how bondings sees it.

There is always a solution to everything though. What I recommend, is doing a little technical work to make Frihost "smart." We should have our own user area (keep forum page how it is, add new area to site). In this area, we should be able to select our interests from a lot of categories. Depending on what things you choose that interest you should determine what shows up in your user dashboard. For example, I like design. I also like cars. Checking these two subjects (you would probably choose a lot more), posts from the design forums and the vehicles forums (maybe it could even be more broad, grabbing keywords as well from thread titles) would show up in my dashboard.

This way we would have our own area in which posts we are more likely to have interest in will display. However we would still have the option to visit the current forum page this way we aren't limited.

I've had this idea for a while and I have even more I could add to it to make it extremely user friendly, but I'll save the rest to myself and perhaps bondings if he ever chimes in.

This would take a little coding work, part of the reason I never really brought it up. But it really would solve the issue about a large amount of forum categories. I think it would even increase our chances in replying to a post as well be seeing nearly every thread on Frihost that would interest us.
Blaster
Ghost I like the dashboard idea. I hope bondings would have the time to code something like this. I could see this being a good advancement for frihost.
deanhills
Ankhanu wrote:
I kinda like the mouse-over thing.

Really, I don't quite understand the aversion to sub-forums;
I totally agree with you Ankhanu. If someone doesn't like the idea of a Forum they can do the General Chat Forum in combination with View Unanswered Posts and it will almost be the equivalent of the suggestion in this thread. I actually like the View Unanswered Posts section as it often comes up with a lucky packet of blog posts as well. In combo with a variety of other Forums.
ocalhoun
Blaster wrote:
Ghost I like the dashboard idea. I hope bondings would have the time to code something like this. I could see this being a good advancement for frihost.

Hm... similar to the dashboard idea would be to let users hide forums of their choice...

Like... I never go to places like history, health and beauty, or the language forums (except for an occasional foray into Spanish... been years since I did that).
Being able to hide the places I never go would simplify things for me a bit.
Ghost Rider103
If there will ever be a time when bondings modifies something so heavily, he may as well make it extremely sophisticated.

Allowing users to hide forums could possibly leave some forums useless. So allowing to display likely interested topics and view the current forum page would allow for maximum posting capabilities from the users.

Otherwise, if you hide a forum, you're likely to never enter it again. We wouldn't want people forgetting what's there.
Blaster
allthough that would be awesome ocalhoun. I agree with ghost. Every now and again I look in some forum catagories I don't tend to go into.
Related topics
Sports forum "football" threads.
The Basics (php, mysql etc)
Email from Yahoo! and AOL will be CHARGED
Master Tutorial on SEO
PHP image uploads with progress bar AND resizing? [Resolved]
Space Cowboy Online
Help on making a web page
MANOFGAMES ADVERTISING - Not available
Suggestion about the new reporting system.
FRI$ to Buy Rank Icons?
Help me about Drop Down List Boxe?
Video Editing Tutorial needed. Paying 800 Fri$
Replies to posts.
Christian Landmark Tree Cut Down In U.K.
Reply to topic    Frihost Forum Index -> General -> Suggestions

FRIHOST HOME | FAQ | TOS | ABOUT US | CONTACT US | SITE MAP
© 2005-2011 Frihost, forums powered by phpBB.