FRIHOSTFORUMSSEARCHFAQTOSBLOGSCOMPETITIONS
You are invited to Log in or Register a free Frihost Account!


Merging vs. locking duplicate threads .... ?





deanhills
Is there any possibility of merging duplicate threads, rather than locking one of the duplicate threads, as sometimes there are really worthwhile discussions in both? Also, when the duplicate thread is locked, it still stays a duplicate, whereas if it is merged with its duplicate, then there is no duplicate any more? It would make the searches also much more streamlined, as when one looks at the "Related Topics" there are more duplicate threads on the same topic.
Ghost Rider103
I don't think all duplicate threads need to be merged. Some duplicate threads (actually a lot) are about the same thing and will just start up the same discussion over again.

There is no problem in merging two duplicate topics, and is actually done more often than you would think. But not all duplicate threads need to be merged.

Some are really almost exact duplicate threads, and wouldn't really contribute anything to the topic that is already started up.
ocalhoun
There is the point about search results and 'similar topics' results...

Perhaps an option to exclude locked threads could be added to the search, and locked threads could always be excluded from the similar topics?
That would prevent those locked duplicates from cluttering them up.
deanhills
Ghost Rider103 wrote:
I don't think all duplicate threads need to be merged. Some duplicate threads (actually a lot) are about the same thing and will just start up the same discussion over again.

There is no problem in merging two duplicate topics, and is actually done more often than you would think. But not all duplicate threads need to be merged.

Some are really almost exact duplicate threads, and wouldn't really contribute anything to the topic that is already started up.
Totally agreed with everything you say. Some threads are genuinely duplicates, and of no value at all. So would it not be justified to delete those, rather than just lock them? And merge the duplicate threads that do have value and merit for being merged? That would be my main preference. If that is not possible, I like Ocalhoun's suggestion of the locked threads being excluded in our searches, and also excluded from the "Related Topics" section.
mathiaus
I personally try to....

Spam (remove) - When topic is rubbish or duplicate and rubbish
Lock - When topic is duplicate but content is good, not suitable for merging.
Merge - When duplicate topics exists and the logical structure of either topic would not be destroyed by merging.

I don't merge often as while duplicate topics exist, the way many of our members converse is like a standard conversation. Merging the two would be like throwing & mixing two similar but different conversations together. Disaster!
The lower quality one or one with fewer posts or one with most rubbish responses or just the latest one would be locked by me.
Ghost Rider103
Mathiaus is right. When merging a topic it's just like throwing in random stuff during a conversation and confuses people.

But again, there is times where merging is a good idea.
deanhills
mathiaus wrote:
I personally try to....

Spam (remove) - When topic is rubbish or duplicate and rubbish
Lock - When topic is duplicate but content is good, not suitable for merging.
Merge - When duplicate topics exists and the logical structure of either topic would not be destroyed by merging.

I don't merge often as while duplicate topics exist, the way many of our members converse is like a standard conversation. Merging the two would be like throwing & mixing two similar but different conversations together. Disaster!
The lower quality one or one with fewer posts or one with most rubbish responses or just the latest one would be locked by me.
Those sound like super guidelines Mathiaus. I particularly like the first one on spam. We really get a great number of topics that are genuine rubbish, usually posted by beginners being very creative, wish there could be a formula where those threads could automatically evaporate, especially when the spammer creates a number of one-liner or copy-paste threads consecutively in the same forum.
Related topics
Rules for posting in the General Chat forum
Spanish Language Subforum
Español.
HURRY GET A DOMAIN NAME FREE!!!
Computer Specs
Closed topics just when you need them most.
i just wanna investgate how many chinese here?
Mac vs. PC?
XBOX 360 Release Dates
What kind of forums do you like?
harry potter
Dogs or Cats ?
Why do moderators COntinuously close threads?
Provision in Report Function for Duplicate Threads?
Reply to topic    Frihost Forum Index -> General -> Suggestions

FRIHOST HOME | FAQ | TOS | ABOUT US | CONTACT US | SITE MAP
© 2005-2011 Frihost, forums powered by phpBB.