FRIHOSTFORUMSSEARCHFAQTOSBLOGSDIRECTORY
You are invited to Log in or Register a Frihost Account!

Is Really Indian did find water on Moon ?

 


gurram533
India's own Moon Impact Probe (MIP) on board the country's maiden lunar craft had discovered water on the moon, a finding confirmed by US
space agency NASA's probe that was also aboard Chandrayaan-1, India's top space scientist G Madhavan Nair said here on Friday.

India's first lunar mission had made a "path-breaking and real discovery" by establishing the presence of water on the moon, Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) chairman Nair said.

While expressing pride in the achievement, Nair added: "But the water is not in the form of sea or lake or puddle or drops. It is embedded on the surface in minerals and rocks."

Apart from India's MIP, the Moon Mineralogy Mapper (M3) of NASA on board Chandrayaan-1 confirmed the presence of water. The lunar mission had to be aborted Aug 30 after it lost radio contact with Earth.

According to Nair, the quantity found is much larger than expected

On whether water can be extracted, Nair said: Yes, we can. But one tonne of soil may yield half a litre.

Nair said MIP picked up signals about the presence of water as it journeyed down to land on the moon surface.

One of the main objectives of Chandrayaan-1 was to look for the presence of water. Our MIP confirmed it

He said they had indications of the finding way back in June, but waited all these days to make it public as they wanted the findings to come out in a scientific journal first.
The volume of data collected from Chandrayaan-1 is phenomenal. It may take six months to three years to analyse it
ocalhoun
How come they didn't find any water in the rocks the US brought back to Earth from the Moon? Or were they just unlucky?
Moonspider
ocalhoun wrote:
How come they didn't find any water in the rocks the US brought back to Earth from the Moon? Or were they just unlucky?


They could not say so conclusively from those brought back because they were not sealed in a manner that would have kept them from being contaminated.

Respectfully,
M
deanhills
Moonspider wrote:
ocalhoun wrote:
How come they didn't find any water in the rocks the US brought back to Earth from the Moon? Or were they just unlucky?


They could not say so conclusively from those brought back because they were not sealed in a manner that would have kept them from being contaminated.

Respectfully,
M
Guess that is a good reason for a quick trip to the moon again? Smile
harismushtaq
I think it is time for India to build a dam over the water source on the moon.
deanhills
harismushtaq wrote:
I think it is time for India to build a dam over the water source on the moon.
And a pipe from the moon to earth .... Smile Wonder how the rights to the water will be working ?
ocalhoun
deanhills wrote:

Guess that is a good reason for a quick trip to the moon again? Smile

I guess it is, since they're sending a rocket to go bomb the moon, then look for water in the debris.
xalophus
gurram533 wrote:
Apart from India's MIP, the Moon Mineralogy Mapper (M3) of NASA on board Chandrayaan-1 confirmed the presence of water.

And this is the same mission that was being criticized by sensationalist media for being too expensive and a waste of money ( which it was not )
It also won one of this year's awards from American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics.
harismushtaq
In the whole story, something confuses me. Moon is not very far away from earth and we are able to see all sides of moon from earth at different times and different regions of earth. The technology of observing constituents of astronimican bodies has become very advanced and we are able to predict composition of jupitor and saturn and even sun where no manned or unmanned space mission has ever reached. There have been humans on the moon a couple of times and they would have felt thrist as the journey was long and would have searched for water.

It is somewhat confusing why we were not able to find water in a so close moon for this much time when we were able to find things on mars. May be a recent raining.
xalophus
harismushtaq wrote:
we are able to see all sides of moon from earth at different times and different regions of earth.

Really ?
I always thought different.

NASA wrote:
The other hemisphere -- the far side -- is always turned away from Earth.
...
A slight motion called libration enables us to see about 59 percent of the moon's surface at different times.
...
http://www.nasa.gov/worldbook/moon_worldbook.html
ocalhoun
xalophus wrote:
harismushtaq wrote:
we are able to see all sides of moon from earth at different times and different regions of earth.

Really ?
I always thought different.

NASA wrote:
The other hemisphere -- the far side -- is always turned away from Earth.
...
A slight motion called libration enables us to see about 59 percent of the moon's surface at different times.
...
http://www.nasa.gov/worldbook/moon_worldbook.html

Quite true. what harismushtaq may have meant was that there is no 'dark side' of the moon. The side referred to as the dark side actually gets just as much light as the other side, a tiny bit more, actually, since it isn't subject to eclipses.
Related topics

NASA finds water on the moon
Indian scientists find answers that eluded Einstein
the 9/11 truth
Bottle of water anyone?
Aliens - Myth or reality?

Was there any point to sending men to the moon?
The Sun God, anyone?
Global Warming
I'm thinking about walking around the world.
Macbeth Ebook

Another Asteroid Collision With Earth
Scientific Predictions from the Quran (+other Holy Books?)
i am pondering on this idea....
Do you believe in Aliens ?
Is nanotechnology immoral?
Reply to topic    Frihost Forum Index -> Lifestyle and News -> Discuss World News

FRIHOST HOME | FAQ | TOS | ABOUT US | CONTACT US | SITE MAP
© 2005-2007 Frihost, forums powered by phpBB.